Dialogue on governance to develop sustainable forest landscapes for production of wood for energy and the bioeconomy
Online workshop with Virtual Field Tours in Northern and Eastern Europe and North America
Welcome to the website of the online workshop “Dialogue on governance to develop sustainable forest landscapes for production of wood for energy and the bioeconomy”.
The goal of this workshop is to engage stakeholders and bring them together to discuss the benefits and challenges to governing sustainability of forest management, with particular emphasis on forest bioenergy. This includes questions related to calculation and modeling of forest carbon and climate impacts.
The geographic focus is on boreal and temperate forests in Northern and Eastern Europe, and North America. You will have the opportunity to join virtual field tours in in these regions, listen to presentations, and interactively discuss the benefits and challenges to governing sustainability of forest landscapes.
The workshop is free for all, but registration is required to participate.
Sustainable forest management and bioenergy in the Baltic states
12 October 2021, 14.00-18.00 Eastern European time (EET)
Forest management for production of wood and biomass for bioenergy relates to a range of policy areas, with climate change, carbon and biodiversity aspects being some of the most discussed for the moment. With a focus on the three Baltic states, this session seeks to inform the discussion and explore the benefits and challenges of various strategies in how they balance goals for climate mitigation, biodiversity and wood production.
Please find recorded Sessions here
Verification of compliance with sustainability requirements for forest bioenergy
13 October 2021, 14.00-18.00 Eastern European time (EET)
In order to achieve the potential benefits of forest bioenergy, it is essential to be able to verify that the wood production and harvesting is compliant with agreed sustainability requirements. In this session, we will explore the strengths and weaknesses of different types of approaches to the verification of such requirements applicable to different types of forest owners, including the effectiveness, practicality, management complexity, costs, and capacity requirements.
Please find recorded Sessions here
How to calculate and model where and when forest bioenergy can help to save carbon emissions?
26 October 2021, 14.00-18.00 Eastern European time (EET)
There is great interest in quantifying how forests can contribute to climate change mitigation as a sink of carbon, and through production of wood to substitute fossil fuel intensive alternatives. In this session, we will discuss different approaches, methodologies and models to calculate the impacts of forest wood and bioenergy production on forest carbon and greenhouse gas balances.
Questions include which approaches, methodologies and models exist; what are their advantages and disadvantages when used for different purposes; and what development is needed to increase their accuracy, make decisions with real impact, and increase their usefulness for the purpose of governance.
Research to underpin future policies related to sustainable forest management and wood end-uses
27 October 2021, 14.00-18.00 Eastern European time (EET)
Governance systems are more likely to be trusted and seen as legitimate, if rigorous science underpins their requirements. Based on the discussions in the previous three sessions of this workshop, we explore what are the most critical knowledge gaps to be addressed and establish collaborations to support policy and management decision-making related to sustainable forest management and the production of wood for multiple of purposes.
Sustainable forest management and bioenergy in the Baltic statesTuesday, 12 October 2021 14.00-18.00 Eastern European Summer Time (EEST) |
Meelis Seedre (moderator) I love forest and I can see the forest behind the trees! I have spent all my life trying to understand forest, during the past 15 years mostly scientifically. Today, I develop and implement forest policy for Estonian 2.3 million hectares of forest. Previoulsly, I was leading the broad strategic impact evaluation of Estonian Forestry Development Plan 2030. Where it was my job to make sure that the plan will be as good as possible. I have been one of the architects of the novel evaluation methodology. My expertise is focused on boreal and temperate forest carbon dynamics, growth, disturbances and management. Also on climate change effects, mitigation and adaptation, biodiversity and recently continuous cover forestry (i.e. uneven-aged forestry). I am especially well informed about Nordic and Baltic forestry. I believe forest and forestry have a lot to offer for the world. My work has included complex project management, methodology development, broad impact evaluation, field and laboratory work, statistical modelling, systematic reviewing, lecturing, presenting, mentoring, supervising, journal editing and peer-reviewing. I have written many scientific and popular science articles, opinions and grant applications. I have participated in many public opinion panels, TV shows and press conferences. |
Āris Jansons Āris is leading the development of tree breeding program for main commercial tree species in Latvia, now being implemented in practice, to produce seed material for regeneration of ⁓10,000 ha of forest annually. Currently. His main research topics are related to forest adaptation (natural disturbances, such as wind and fire), including development of forest wind resistance models and recommendations for establishment and management of resilient forest stands. He also conducts assessment and modelling of carbon balances in old-growth and pristine forest. |
Kristjan Tõnisson He has contributed to the structural reforms of public forest administration in Estonia, worked as an auditor of FSC forest certification standards in many countries of Europe as well as Russia. Since 2007, he has been working in the State Forest Management Centre of Estonia. In his current position as member of the management board, he is responsible for nature protection and restoration activities as well and visitor management. |
Guntars Šnepsts Guntars has been working at the Latvian Forest Research Institute "SILAVA" since 2005. His work focus on the Latvian national forest inventory, where he organizes the work of field teams, and perform control measurements and annual calculations of forest resources. He is also the Head of the SILAVA Forest Resource Forecasting System. He participate in various scientific research related to forestry and forest resources. |
Nerijus Kupstaitis Nerijus Kupstaitis is Head of the Forest Policy Group, Ministry of Environment of the Republic of Lithuania, where he was previously the Chief Adviser of the Policy Group of Nature Protection and Forest Department. Before 2017, he held several leading and specialist positions in the Forest Department of the Ministry of Environment of the Republic of Lithuania. Nerijus’ key expertise is within forest policy, silviculture, forest management and other forestry-related fields. He has comprehensive expert knowledge and more than 20 years of experience with analysis of forestry-related national and EU level legal framework, for example drafting national forestry-related legal acts, including the Law on Forest. He also has comprehensive experience with adaptation of national legal acts to EU legislation and other international commitments in the forest sector. Additionally, Nerijus has more than 20 years’ of experience with preparation of forestry-related national strategy documents and development programmes, and he participated in the creation of the national legal regulatory system for the private forests sector. |
Irisa Mukāne Head of the Nature Census, Nature Conservation Agency in Latvia. |
Ieva Saleniece Ieva Saleniece is LIFE-IP LatViaNature project manager in the Nature Conservation Agency of Latvia. She holds M. Sc degree in Pollution and Environmental Control from the University of Manchester, U.K. and a degree in Law from the University of Latvia. Ieva has extensive experience in the environmental field, and has direct knowledge of climate policy. |
Erik Buchwald Erik Buchwald, forester and ecologist (PhD) at the Danish Nature Agency, has worked with forest management, forest health, Natura 2000 and with natural forest terminology and biodiversity since 1987. For the time being he is national project leader for the implementation of the Danish Government´s 2016-2020 decisions to restore about two thirds of the nation´s state forests to a more natural state and afterwards manage them as minimum-intervention reserves for protection and restoration of biodiversity - thus enlarging the Danish area of forest designated as protected untouched forest from about 6.000 to 75.000 hectares from 2016 to 2026. |
Verification of compliance with sustainability requirements for forest bioenergyWednesday, 13 October 2021, 14.00-18.00 Eastern European Summer Time (EEST) |
Algis Gaižutis (moderator) Chairman, Forest and Land Owners Association of Lithuania. |
Liviu Nichiforel Liviu Nichiforel holds a Master’s degree in Environmental Governance from “Albert-Ludwigs” University of Freiburg, Germany and a PhD in Forest Economics from the “Ștefan cel Mare” University of Suceava. His main research interest refers to the analysis of differences in forest governance frameworks across Europe. His latest national research project proposes the development of a new forest policy framework in Romania. He has also worked as an independent consultant for different projects including the implementation of forest certification in Romania. |
Roman Polyachenko Roman joined SBP in April 2020 as Assurance Manager to oversee and manage SBP’s global operating assurance system. Before joining the team at SBP, he worked for 12 years at the Certification Body, NEPCon, as a Supply Chain Integrity Program Manager. Roman is a forestry professional with international experience within the forestry and timber sector, environmental auditing, assurance systems, and training delivery. As an auditor and manager, he has worked with many different wood processing, biomass, and paper companies in different parts of the world. Other experiences include leading projects, developing training programmes, organising workshops, writing technical handbooks, building assurance procedures, supporting quality management, and supervising a team of technical specialists and auditors. Roman is a trained FSC, PEFC, RSPO Chain of Custody auditor, and was also a lead trainer in NEPCon’s FSC Chain of Custody and Controlled Wood Expert programme. He holds a Master’s degree in Forest Industry from the Estonian University of Life Sciences, and also participated in the Euroforester programme at the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. Roman is based in Estonia. |
Mihkel Jugaste Head of Quality and Certification Systems, AS Graanul Invest, Estonia. |
Gerimantas Gaigalas Gerimantas Gaigalas has Master‘s degree on Forestry (graduated in Lithuanian Academy of Agriculture), BSc degree in Law and Master‘s degree in International Law (graduated in University of Mykolas Romeris) and diploma in programming (Electronic College in Vilnius). He has experience leading the International Relations and Agreements Division in the Ministry of Environment as well as experience working in United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) Papua New Guinea regional office and Institute of Environment Sustainability of EU Commission in Italy. Gerimantas is working in Preferred by Nature since 2013 and now is in the position of Forestry Director for Europe / Russia. He also has experience and is active lead auditor for FSC Forest Management (FM), FSC Chain of Custody (CoC), PEFC CoC, SBP (Sustainable Biomass Program) and FM Legal Source certification schemes. |
Mārcis Sakalaurs |
Aidas Pivoriūnas Aidas is an experienced consultant working as a forest management consult for industry, who is skilled in crisis management, nonprofit organizations, negotiation, sustainable development, and forest management. He holds Licentiate of Philosophy degree in forest economics from The Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. He is currently working with FSC International as Head of Technical Working Group for the Interim National Stewardship Standard for Latvia, and a Moderator and Head of Standard Development Group for National FSC Standard for Lithuania. He is an elected member of the presidium of the Lithuanian Confederation of Industrialists, and of the Board of the Association of Independent Wood Measurers of Lithuania. Additionally, he is an appointed member of the Consultancy Council of Forests under the Ministry of Environment in Lithuania. |
Puneet Dwivedi Dr. Puneet Dwivedi is an Associate Professor of Sustainability Sciences at the University of Georgia Warnell School of Forestry and Natural Resources – the oldest forestry school in the Southern United States established in 1906. He specializes in sustainable bioenergy development, family forest landowners, forest markets, and forest-based ecosystem services. He has published extensively on topics related to the sustainability of southern US forestry resources. He has also advised 20 graduate students and four postdocs as a major professor so far. He was awarded Excellence in Research and Development Award by the Southeastern Chapter of the Society of American Foresters in 2019. |
Rolf Hogan Rolf is a senior international sustainability expert with more than twenty years’ experience promoting international best practice with industry, civil society, government, and UN organisations. He has broad experience in sustainability spanning global biodiversity policy, field conservation programmes, NGO campaigns and working with industry in the transport, energy and FMCG sectors. Rolf has worked with large international NGOs such as WWF and IUCN (International Union for the Conservation of Nature) as well as leading a ‘start-up’ certification organisation – RSB-Roundtable on Sustainable Biomaterials (www.rsb.org). He has also worked as a freelance writer/journalist and managed a diversity of projects across five continents. Rolf’s expertise is in organisational strategy, strategic communications, organisational/project reviews, and stakeholder engagement. He is currently providing consultancy services in collaboration with EarthMind (https://earthmind.org) and as a Senior Associate with INCAS Consulting (www.incasconsulting.com). Current projects include the revision of the theory of change for an international sustainable certification organisation and establishing a national policy coordination mechanism for NGOs in Russia. |
Aiga Grasmane Managing Director, Latvian Forest Owners' Association. |
Andris Vanags Andris Vanags is Latvia Country Manager of Gren – the Northern European green energy company that focuses on developing and providing sustainable energy solutions, primarily district heating, to meet its local communities' needs in their daily lives while having a positive impact on the environment. Andris Vanags has more than 20 years of experience in energy industry, project management, site supervision and energy consulting. He has taken different managerial positions in some of the largest DH companies in Latvia and has worked as a project manager for the construction of several large power plants and boiler plants. Andris Vanags is taking an active role in several NGOs - Latvian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (LTRK), Finnish Chamber of Commerce in Latvia (FCCL), Latvian Renewable Energy Federation (LAEF), Latvia Wind Energy Association, Foreign Investors' Council in Latvia (FICIL), Latvian Association of DH Companies (LSUA) and Latvian Bioenergy Association (LBEA). Andris Vanags is holding University Degree in Engineering from Riga Technical University and has numerous certificates from professional qualification courses. |
Sune Balle-Hansen Sune Balle Hansen is the Biomass Sustainability Lead in Biomass Procurement and Logistics at HOFOR, Greater Copenhagen Utility. HOFOR uses wood pellets and woodchips to fuel its combined heat and power plant that feeds into the Copenhagen district heating grid. Currently, Sune holds the responsibility for operational compliance with HOFOR’s biomass sustainability policies, regulatory requirements and biomass sustainability certifications, which includes regular direct contact with HOFOR’s biomass supply chain. Sune’s career spans engineering and sustainability research in the private sector as well as in academia. He holds an MSc and PhD in Environmental Engineering from the Technical University of Denmark. |
How to calculate and model where and when forest bioenergy can help to save carbon emissions?Tuesday, 26 October 2021, 14.00-18.00 Eastern European Summer Time (EEST) |
Niclas Scott Bentsen (moderator) Niclas’ research and teaching targets four main areas: 1) Biomass resources - Quantification and characterisation of biomass resources from agriculture and forestry on local to global scales, 2) Resource allocation - How can we allocate biomass resources to different uses, mainly energy, to maximise utility and minimise negative impacts, 3) Climate impacts of bioenergy - Although considered carbon neutral bioenergy and biomass exploitation has its impact on GHG gas emissions either through direct GHG emissions, through altered CO2 sequestration potential or through so-called indirect effects mediated by economic dynamics. Quantifying the true climate impact of biomass use requires due consideration of physical, biological and economic dynamics, 4) Sustainability of bioenergy - Sustainability is more that climate impacts. His research also targets quantification of other potential impacts of bioenergy within the environmental, social and economic pillars of sustainability using different tools as e.g. LCA, Lifecycle thinking, Material Flow Analysis. He is the Danish National Team leader of IEA Bioenergy Task 45 on “Climate and Sustainability Effects of Bioenergy within the broader Bioeconomy”. |
Viorel Blujdea Joint Research Centre, Ispra (VA), Italy. Viorel Nelu Bellmondo Blujdea graduated forestry (1993) and has a PhD in forest ecology (2000) from Transilvania University of Brasov (Romania). He is involved in research activities on modelling the carbon dynamics in forest management, wood use and land use conversions. As a researcher he records some 70 publications (h-index = 15, i10-index = 22, 924 citations, according to Google scholar). His professional record includes experience in the private sector, offering technical and scientific support on national GHG inventories, LULUCF accounting and GHG projections for land sector to national governments (developed and developing countries), European Commission, UNDP, World Bank, etc. Currently, he works as a project officer in the Bioeconomy Unit of the Joint Research Center of the European Commission. He is an accredited UNFCCC reviewer for national GHG inventory, national communications and biennial reports and a former independent expert in European Commission LULUCF Expert Group. |
Annikki Mäkelä She is leading the department’s Forest Modelling Research Group, which develops theories and models about tree functioning, structure, and growth, and applies these to examine impacts of forest management under changing environmental conditions and alternative management objectives. The group also belongs to the Helsinki University, Institute for Atmospheric and Earth System Research (INAR). Her basic degree is in systems theory from Helsinki University of Technology (now Aalto University) and her PhD is in forestry. |
Ondřej Tarabus He is also experienced with different forest management certification using FSC standard and has participated in forest management and chain of custody audits in number of different continents. He has been involved in the ISCC and SBP certifications in the early stages of these programs. Ondřej has participated in several development projects in forestry, carbon and biomass fields in Latin America, Asia and Europe. At the moment he is responsible for climate services, including biomass where his involvement is mostly through SBP certification and their own Responsible Biomass program. He is also engaged in different projects in the biomass sustainability field such as SBP Risk Assessment in several countries in Europe, evaluation of different verification systems, benchmarking of certification schemes or smallholder biomass project in Vietnam. |
Carolyn Smyth Carolyn’s research includes assessments of climate change mitigation scenarios for Canada’s forest sector including the ecosystem GHG balance, harvested wood product C tracking, bioenergy and biofuels, and substitution benefits of using wood in place of other emissions-intensive products and fossil fuel burning. In addition, she has contributed to Canada’s National Inventory Reports, Emissions Projection Reports, an IPCC TSU expert meeting on National GHG Inventories, and has collaborated on North American C Modeling through the Commission for Environmental Cooperation. |
Raimonds Kašs Raimonds has graduated from Faculty of Power and Electrical Engineering of Riga Technical University where he obtained a master’s degree in environmental science, previously also bachelor’s degree in electrical science. From 2002 Raimonds works in the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development of the Republic of Latvia. Raimonds’ field of professional activity is development of legal acts and policy planning documents in field of climate policy, implementation of existing Emission Allowance Auctioning Instrument, as well as involvement in preparation of new climate finance mechanisms and instruments in Latvia. Together with colleagues, Raimonds ensures cooperation with other ministries to promote the integration of greenhouse gas emissions and climate resilience objectives into sectoral policies. |
Andis Lazdiņš |
Lars Högbom Associated professor, SkogForsk, Sweden Lars’ research focuses on impacts of forest management and forest operations on forest water, carbon and nutrients, as well as translating research into practical guidance on how to minimize undesirable impacts of forest management. He is also an Adjunct Senior Lecturer at the Department of Forest Ecology and Management at the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. |
Justin Tait Justin Tait is the Head of Sustainability in Europe at Enviva, the world’s largest producer of sustainable wood pellets that provide power and utility companies around the globe with a low-carbon alternative to fossil fuels. Based in the United Kingdom, Mr. Tait is responsible for ensuring that Enviva delivers sustainably sourced “good biomass” to its customers in the UK and Europe that meet globally recognized standards and Enviva’s own Responsible Sourcing Policy Mr. Tait is also responsible for engaging with European policymakers and external stakeholders on regulatory matters pertaining to climate change and environmental stewardship by Enviva. With more than two decades of experience working with several blue-chip companies on sustainable sourcing and on improving operations to reduce energy, water and waste in their supply chains, Mr. Tait joined the Enviva team in 2018. Impassioned to help businesses transition to more sustainable practices at scale, Mr. Tait has collaborated with suppliers, academics, policy makers and NGOs to improve environmental performance and the benefits this can bring to business and actors in their supply chains. Throughout his tenure at Enviva, he has worked to support and promote Enviva’s Responsible Sourcing Policy – wood sourcing guidelines that reflect Enviva’s commitment to the highest standards of sustainability, integrity, forest stewardship and continual improvement – as well as Track & Trace® – an innovative technology for monitoring, tracking and reporting exactly where all Enviva’s wood is sourced. |
Richard Peberdy After university Richard spent 10 years running a small forestry business in North Wales. This was followed by twenty years working for a large forest management company in the UK. From 2012 to the present, Richard has worked for Drax, spending nearly seven years in US South as Drax established supplies from that region, and from Canada (especially British Columbia). Today Richard works closely with suppliers and the Drax sustainability team to monitor the regions from Drax sources. This enables Drax to ensure that its sourcing activities sustain forests and provide low carbon feedstocks to Drax power station and other users of Drax pellets. |
Research to underpin future policies related to sustainable forest management
|
Āris Jansons (moderator) Āris is leading the development of tree breeding program for main commercial tree species in Latvia, now being implemented in practice, to produce seed material for regeneration of ⁓10,000 ha of forest annually. Currently, his main research topics are related to forest adaptation (natural disturbances, such as wind and fire), including development of forest wind resistance models and recommendations for establishment and management of resilient forest stands. He also conducts assessment and modelling of carbon balances in old-growth and pristine forest. |
Lauri Hetemäki Hetemäki has been a Visiting Senior Research Fellow at the Haas Business School, University of California, Berkeley; at the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IIASA), Laxenburg, Austria; and at the Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics, Canberra. Lauri has extensive experience in science-policy support work, e.g. in European Parliament, European Commission and national Governments and Parliaments, as well as coordinating pan-European science-policy studies. He is an author of over 240 scientific and popular publications. Hetemäki is a Fellow of the Royal Swedish Academy of Agriculture and Forestry. |
Joint talk on forest research in the Baltic countries |
Iveta Varnegyrite-Kabasinskiene Senior researcher, Head of Department of Silviculture and Ecology, Lithuanian Research Center for Agriculture and Forestry (LAMMC). Iveta is a Senior researcher and Head of Department of Silviculture and Ecology at Lithuanian Research Center for Agriculture and Forestry (LAMMC). She has received both her BSc and MSc from Lithuanian Agricultural University, Faculty of Forestry, and her PhD from Vytautas Magnus University in Ecology and Environmental Sciences. Currently, her research topics are related to forest ecology, soil and plant chemistry, carbon evaluation, forest biomass in Scots pine forests, effects of climatic conditions on forest ecosystems. |
Diana Lukmine Diana works as a Senior Research at Institute of Forestry, Lithuanian Research Centre of Agriculture and Forestry (LAMMC). Her research activities relate to analysis of the forest management economics and sustainability in public and private forests. Her background in Social Sciences (Economics). Expertise and research interests include evaluation of forest management sustainability, forest policy processes and governance analysis, innovation in the forestry sector, forest ownership types and forest owner’s behaviour. She is co-author of nine books or chapters of books, more than 40 articles in previewed journals, and more than 30 oral presentations in international and national conferences, and participated in more than 30 applied research projects and 9 international projects. |
Andis Lazdins |
Dagnija Lazdina |
Kristi Nigul Forestry is one big part of Kristi’s life. She has a BSc and MSc in forestry from the Estonian University of Life Sciences and is currently finalizing her PhD studies. She has been working in forest sector for more than 10 years, but have been related with forestry most of her life. For the purpose of her PhD studies, she also studied and worked with other scientists abroad, for example a semester at University of Minnesota, in the USA. In her daily work, she deals with several aspects of forest management, including certifications (PEFC, FSC, and SBP), investments in forestry, and communication with clients. She has been involved in different certification working groups, for example to update the Estonian National PEFC forest management standard. She also spends much of her spare time in the nature, for example hiking or fishing. |
Joint talk on forest research in North America |
C. Tattersall (Tat) Smith Dr. Tat Smith held the positions as Professor and Dean (Forestry) and Department of Geography and Planning at University of Toronto 2005-2019, and held corresponding positions at Department of Forest Science at Texas A&M University; New Zealand Forest Research Institute; and Department of Forest Resources, University of New Hampshire. He served in international collaboration leadership roles for IEA Bioenergy from 1994 to 2019; was founding member and past Chair of the Board of Directors of the Invasive Species Centre; Past President of the Canadian Institute of Forestry; Fellow of the Society of American Foresters; and past member of the Board of the Sustainable Forestry Initiative (SFI). Tat’s major research contributions have been in the area of developing sustainable forest management (SFM) systems for bioenergy feedstock production and land application of wastewater effluent and biosolids to determine the environmental impacts of bioenergy production in plantation and natural forests; the utility of environmental certification systems defining SFM standards and criteria and indicators for developing reliable SFM practices; and the impact of intensive harvesting on forest ecosystem nutrient and carbon cycling and stocks and site productivity. |
David M. Morris Dr. Morris received both his BScF and MScF from Lakehead University and his PhD from the University of Guelph in Environmental Biology. Dave has been a research scientist with the Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry since 1986, and is currently the Stand Ecology Program Leader at the Centre for Northern Forest Ecosystem Research in Thunder Bay, ON. His research program focuses on nutrient cycling in boreal systems, with particular emphasis on evaluating the impacts of forest disturbance, including biomass harvesting systems, on stand structural development, stand nutrition, and productivity. His research has been instrumental in the development of Ontario’s forest management guidelines with respect to biofibre harvest, with ongoing research efforts designed to evaluate the effectiveness of these guidelines within an adaptive management framework. |
Puneet Dwivedi Dr. Puneet Dwivedi is an Associate Professor of Sustainability Sciences at the University of Georgia Warnell School of Forestry and Natural Resources – the oldest forestry school in the Southern United States established in 1906. He specializes in sustainable bioenergy development, family forest landowners, forest markets, and forest-based ecosystem services. He has published extensively on topics related to the sustainability of southern US forestry resources. He has also advised 20 graduate students and four postdocs as a major professor so far. He was awarded Excellence in Research and Development Award by the Southeastern Chapter of the Society of American Foresters in 2019. |
Joint talk on forest research in the Nordic countries |
Helja-Sisko Helmisaari Dr. Helmisaari received both her BScF and MScF from University of Helsinki and her PhD from the University of Joensuu (currently University of Eastern Finland) in Forest Sciences. Heljä-Sisko has been professor in Forest Soil Science since 2010, before which she worked at the Finnish Forest Research Institute (currently Natural Resources Institute Finland). Her research has focused on biogeochemistry, especially carbon and nutrient dynamics in forest ecosystems in relation to environmental changes and forest management, including biomass harvesting. In 2012 she was the main organizer of a workshop on Forest bioenergy and soil sustainability, that led to the collection and review of biomass harvesting guidelines from different jurisdictions around the world by 16 researchers, finally published in 2021 (Titus et al. 2021, Sustainable forest biomass: a review of current residue harvesting guidelines. Energy, Sustainability and Society (2021) 11:10). |
Nicholas Clarke Dr. Nicholas Clarke holds a PhD in analytical chemistry applied to natural fresh waters, from the Royal Institute of Technology in Stockholm. He has worked at NIBIO for 25 years, mostly on environmental issues related to forest and forestry, including the carbon cycle, forests and water, and the effect of forestry measures on forest soil and water. He has led and participated in several Norwegian and international projects on the ecological effects of intensive biomass harvesting for bioenergy. He was previously chair of the Expert Panel on Deposition of ICP Forests. |
Lars Högbom Lars’ research focuses on impacts of forest management and forest operations on forest water, carbon and nutrients, as well as translating research into practical guidance on how to minimize undesirable impacts of forest management. He is also an Adjunct Senior Lecturer at the Department of Forest Ecology and Management at the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. |
Inge Stupak Inge holds a degree in Forestry, and a PhD in Forest Ecology. Her research focus since 1993 has been on the impacts of woody biomass production and intensive harvesting in forest on nutrient and carbon balances and site fertility. Since 2000, she has coordinated and worked in Nordic-Baltic various research projects and networks, and since 2006, she has been engaged in international collaborations under IEA Bioenergy, especially publications on governing forest biomass sustainability. Since 2009, she has been co-responsible for planning, implementation, data analysis and publishing results from the national Danish Forest Soil Inventory, as a basis for the national inventory reporting of LULUCF greenhouse gas emissions. She was National Team Leader in IEA Bioenergy Task 43, Biomass Feedstocks for Energy Markets (2013-2018), and is Alternate National Team Leader of IEA Bioenergy Task 45, Climate and Sustainability Effects of Bioenergy within the broader Bioeconomy (2019-2021). |
A cross-section of forest sector and society involved with and concerned about the governance and documentation of sustainable forest bioenergy and bioeconomy supply chains, for example forest landowners, wood pellet companies, wood chip producers, traders, private state and federal foresters, forest industry, bioenergy utilities, state conservation organizations, public and private providers of relevant data for verification, staff of forestry certification systems and certification bodies, policy makers, academia, NGOs, consultants, media, the general public.
European demand for wood fuels as feedstock in energy production has grown in the past decades. It may stagnate, grow, or decrease depending on the public discourse and societal political priorities, but it seems evident that there will increasingly be need for wood and forest biomass as raw materials for the bioeconomy, and replacement or more fossil fuel intensive alternatives.
Domestic wood, wood chips, and wood pellets have been used for heat and power through decades since the oil embargo in the 1970s. Since the 2010s forest biomass, especially in the form of wood pellets for heat and power production, have increasingly been traded internationally, with actors in the Baltic States and North America supplying a significant share of the current market.
Such resources are also expected to provide a considerable share of feedstock for the broader bioeconomy in a longer time perspective. It will require that the forest management is able to deliver a wide range of industry raw materials for lumber, biochemicals, biomaterials, bioproducts, and wood fuels.
The public discourse around the use of forests to produce wood for different purposes differ among countries, but concerns are increasing about the risks of bioenergy harvesting and forest management practices to ecosystems services, and climate benefits of different wood end-uses are being questioned, especially the use of wood for bioenergy.
Across Europe and North America, there is a call for proof that forests are being managed sustainably, with climate benefits. Additionally, there is a call for formally setting aside forests with no or minimum management activity where conservation is the primary goal of the management.
The European Union has decided on a goal to conserve 30% of its land by 2030, as a part of the new Green Deal. The strategy focuses especially on protection of primary forests and old-growth, as well as afforestation. Likewise, the U.S.A. recently committed to conserve 30% of U.S. land by 2030.
This situation has created a pressure that forest owners and management must document that forests are managed sustainably with no harm to biodiversity, soil, water and climate. It must also be documented by wood energy end-users that climate benefits from their bioenergy supply chains is significant.
The requirements are implemented through public and private governance systems, often in so-called co-regulation systems, where public regulation for example rely on private certification for actors to show compliance. The governance as a whole can be a complex system of various sectorial laws and regulations, best practice management guidelines, recommendations, private certification systems, and individual company business strategies.
These systems represent some level of societal agreement on how to balance economic, environmental and social sustainability goals.
It is not equally easy for all types of forest owners to provide the required documentation if they wish to sell to markets with sustainability requirements. History and forest ownership structures provide very different starting points and opportunities for governance.
For example, private forest owners own the larger shares of forest in the Nordic countries. Forests are required to contribute to societal goals but otherwise generally enjoy great freedom in management, which has historically been very active. In East-European countries, forests are, or were until the independence, owned by the State, with prescriptive management requirements, and relatively low levels of harvesting compared to the Nordic countries.
Restitution of forest land to thousands of small private forest owners in the Baltic states together with deregulation and increased access to international wood markets have paved the way to increasing level of harvesting, which is now causing public concern.
In Canada, a large share of the forest is state owned with private actors being granted contracts to harvest the land, with periodic contract renewal. Southeastern USA is marked by a large share of private forests, with a vast number of small scale forest owners. Forest owners has historically enjoyed great freedom in how they manage their land, also for conversion among land uses, depending, for example, on the development in the markets.
Forest management unit certification has been successfully implemented by many larger forest management units, but the approach is still a challenge to smaller forest owners. Sustainable sourcing standards and newer risk-based approaches provide opportunity for small-scale forest owners to supply sustainability certified forest biomass, without certification at the forest management unit level, allowing industries to source certified material from larger areas.
This is currently an important approach in the Baltic States and southeastern USA, where it is unlikely that a larger share of newer or long existing small, privately owned forests will become individually certified, or be able to organize around large scale group certificates as in Finland. Such approaches may also become important in relation to sustainability criteria to maintain or increase carbon stocks and biological diversity that are best addressed at a landscape scale.
A major challenge to the design of effective governance systems is the presence of imperfect knowledge, variability, uncertainty and complexity, resulting in poor levels of predictability of forest management impacts on sustainability values on a specific site. This calls for tools that are able to identify changes in who the stakeholders are, political and stakeholder priorities, integrate new knowledge, and rapidly change direction if unintended impacts occur.
There is currently a shift from public to participation of more private governance, which seems to result in a shift to focus on solutions to specific environmental and social problems, compared to having people participate in an inclusive manner. This has suggested as a root cause in the criticism of systems governing sustainability of bioenergy. An adaptive governance system can be a platform, from which such trade-offs can be made with the acceptance of the involved parties.
It has thus been argued that less effective and efficient solutions must sometimes be chosen over better ones, because political needs or societal expectations require it, for example, for the enforcement to be perceived as impartial and fair.
The ideology of an adaptive governance setting is the iterative and gradual improvement of existing sustainability governance regimes. The question is how to continuously improve the tools, data, research and monitoring systems to maintain, re-gain or improve legitimacy and public trust that the forest management is sustainable in how it produces wood for the whole range of end uses needed by society.
The figure below illustrates an adaptive governance model with elements found to be critical in an adaptive governance setting.
With this in mind, we invite all interested parties to a discussion of these topics.

The figure illustrates an adaptive governance model with elements found to be critical in an adaptive governance setting.
Inge Stupak (coordinator) |
University of Copenhagen, Denmark |
|
Andis Lazdins |
Latvian State Forest Research Institute (SILAVA), Latvia. | |
C. Tattersall Smith |
University of Toronto, Canada |
|
Dagnija Lazdina |
Latvian State Forest Research Institute (SILAVA), Latvia |
|
Dave M. Morris |
Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources, Canada |
|
Diana Lukminė |
(LAMMC), Lithuania,Lithuanian Research Center for Agriculture and Forestry, |
|
Helja-Sisko Helmisaari |
University of Helsinki, Finland |
|
Iveta Varnagiryte-Kabasinskiene |
Lithuanian Research Center for Agriculture and Forestry, (LAMMC), Lithuania |
|
Kristi Nigul |
Estonian University of Life Sciences (EMU) and HD Forest, Estonia |
|
Lars Högbom |
SkogForsk, Sweden |
|
Liviu Nichiforel |
nichiforel@usv.ro |
Stefan cel Mare University of Suceava, Romania |
Nicholas Clarke |
Norwegian Institute of Bioeconomy Research (NIBIO), Norway |
|
Puneet Dwivedi |
University of Georgia, USA |
The IEA Bioenergy Technology Collaboration Programme (TCP) is organised under the auspices of the International Energy Agency (IEA) but is functionally and legally autonomous. Views, findings and publications of the IEA Bioenergy TCP do not necessarily represent the views or policies of the IEA Secretariat or its individual member countries.
Save the dates
12 October 2021, 14.00-18.00
13 October 2021, 14.00-18.00
26 October 2021, 14.00-18.00
27 October 2021, 14.00-18.00
Eastern European time (EET)
Contact
Inge Stupak
ism@ign.ku.dk
+45 41 41 11 56