Plumasite-type corundum occurrences in the Nattivit area in South-East Greenland offer a unique opportunity to study corundum formation in-situ where pegmatites intruded into metamorphosed lherzolite and dunite of the Archean-Paleoproterozoic continental crust. The Nattivit area, located in the Isertoq Terrane of North Atlantic Craton, forms part of the overriding plate during convergence of the Nagssugtoqidian orogen (1910-1840 Ma). New field observations and elemental and isotopic geochemical analysis provide further insights in the history of crustal convergence, its exhumation and how corundum was formed. The continental crust in the area consists of metamorphosed mafic to ultramafic rocks and tonalite-trondhjemite-granodiorite (TTG) gneisses, where the mafic rocks in the Isertoq Terrane yield a εNd T_DM model age of 3000–2800 Ma. Dunite and lherzolite sills/dikes intruded the mafic rocks before the intrusion of the TTG sheets. The intrusion ages for the TTG obtained from zircon U-Pb geochronology are 2818 ± 8 Ma, 2760 ± 13 Ma to 2667 ± 7 Ma. U-Pb zircon data, zircon textures and Th/U ratios indicate metamorphism occurred at 2698 ± 7 Ma to 2629 ± 11 Ma, 2500–2400 Ma and 1900–1600 Ma. Whole rock geochemical data of mafic to ultramafic rocks show a continental arc affinity, with negative Ta, Nb and positive Pb anomalies. A metasomatic event at 2390 ± 70 Ma partly reset the isotopic signature in the mafic to ultramafic rocks. A marked absence of ages between 2350 and 2100 Ma in the TTG zircon age populations exists, indicating a period with minimal magmatic and/or metamorphic activity. The metamorphic mineral assemblages of the schist, amphibolite, ultramafic rocks and metasomatic reaction zones in ultramafic rocks indicate upper to medium–high amphibolite facies conditions. Kyanite in the metasomatic reaction zones in ultramafic rocks indicate the higher end of the temperature and pressure range above 4.2–10 kbar and 530–800 °C, similar to estimates from dolerite dikes in the Kitak area. The syn-tectonic pegmatites with an intrusion age of 1843 ± 4 Ma formed corundum. The new data indicate that the pegmatite melt/fluid and the geotectonic setting are defining factors for generating plumasite-type corundum.