Introducing a flat ontology into landscape research: a case study of water governance experiments in South Africa
Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskrift › Tidsskriftartikel › Forskning › fagfællebedømt
Standard
Introducing a flat ontology into landscape research : a case study of water governance experiments in South Africa. / Raffn, Jakob; Christensen, Andreas Aagaard; De Witt, Marlene; Lewis, Cathie; Büchner-Marais, Charon.
I: Landscape Ecology, Bind 38, 2023, s. 4193–4209.Publikation: Bidrag til tidsskrift › Tidsskriftartikel › Forskning › fagfællebedømt
Harvard
APA
Vancouver
Author
Bibtex
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
T1 - Introducing a flat ontology into landscape research
T2 - a case study of water governance experiments in South Africa
AU - Raffn, Jakob
AU - Christensen, Andreas Aagaard
AU - De Witt, Marlene
AU - Lewis, Cathie
AU - Büchner-Marais, Charon
PY - 2023
Y1 - 2023
N2 - ContextContemporary resource management paradigms within the developed world build on an understanding of human agency as ontologically distinct from the mode of existence of plants and animals. Because of this perspective, which gives priority to human agency, policies typically take their point of departure with human societies and associated ecosystems deemed of particular value.ObjectivesAs an alternative to this worldview, social theorists have introduced what is known as “flat ontology”, where all beings are bestowed equal rights to negotiate their existence. To explore the implications of introducing such an understanding into landscape management, a participatory planning process for water allocation was developed and tested in a case study in the Eerste River Catchment in South Africa.MethodsThe planning process was mediated using the approach “politics of nature” (PoN), which aims to operationalize flat ontology to renegotiate water allocation based on the needs of all beings instead of the desire of a subset of humans. PoN allowed participants to playfully co-develop a common ontology and value-set. Data documenting these processes were collected digitally and analysed.ResultsResults indicate that the approach engendered a rethinking of key relationships between human agency and ecosystem functionality, illustrating a potential for PoN-approaches to be deployed for governance of complex landscapes.ConclusionsOn the basis of experiments using PoN-methodology in the context of watershed management, it is discussed how the introduction of a flat ontology in landscape research, could inspire new ways of designing and intervening with collaborative resource management processes.
AB - ContextContemporary resource management paradigms within the developed world build on an understanding of human agency as ontologically distinct from the mode of existence of plants and animals. Because of this perspective, which gives priority to human agency, policies typically take their point of departure with human societies and associated ecosystems deemed of particular value.ObjectivesAs an alternative to this worldview, social theorists have introduced what is known as “flat ontology”, where all beings are bestowed equal rights to negotiate their existence. To explore the implications of introducing such an understanding into landscape management, a participatory planning process for water allocation was developed and tested in a case study in the Eerste River Catchment in South Africa.MethodsThe planning process was mediated using the approach “politics of nature” (PoN), which aims to operationalize flat ontology to renegotiate water allocation based on the needs of all beings instead of the desire of a subset of humans. PoN allowed participants to playfully co-develop a common ontology and value-set. Data documenting these processes were collected digitally and analysed.ResultsResults indicate that the approach engendered a rethinking of key relationships between human agency and ecosystem functionality, illustrating a potential for PoN-approaches to be deployed for governance of complex landscapes.ConclusionsOn the basis of experiments using PoN-methodology in the context of watershed management, it is discussed how the introduction of a flat ontology in landscape research, could inspire new ways of designing and intervening with collaborative resource management processes.
U2 - 10.1007/s10980-021-01374-9
DO - 10.1007/s10980-021-01374-9
M3 - Journal article
C2 - 34840425
VL - 38
SP - 4193
EP - 4209
JO - Landscape Ecology
JF - Landscape Ecology
SN - 0921-2973
ER -
ID: 285945196